There are a few things to consider - this is Sabaton's first
live album, and the first outing with the new line-up, vocalist Joakim Broden
and bassist Par Sundstrom remaining the only constant members. Also, this is an
audio only review of an album that is being released as a live DVD/Blu-Ray.
While the vocal talents of Broden are never really tested in this performance, I
very much enjoyed the vocals, harmonies and accompanying vocals in general. Most
songs are in a lower key, too. Probably done just to sound heavier. Whatever the
reason, it works.
It does appear that significant attention has been weighted on the new arrivals.
They have confidently taken over the reigns from their predecessors and Sabaton
clearly want to demonstrate this. Broden mentions to the crowd that they are
very thankful for the reception the new additions have received throughout the
tour. The guitarists are given the chance to demonstrate their skills which they
do very well, it must be said - though unfortunately this not so much the case
for the drums, which are often slightly overpowered throughout the album. In
fact, in terms of the overall sound it's quite keyboard heavy, even for Power
Metal, and in a few places that does blot out most other things, but it is very
intermittent.
The album also feels a little jumbled to me in places - the formula tends to be
slow song to a faster song to a slow song to a faster song which, to me
personally, becomes a little tiresome. I admit I do not know if this is
something that is usual for Sabaton gigs. Besides, this is an album review, not
a live gig review, so you might think "Why is the order of songs important
on a CD?" Well to me it's due to this: I, like many, have a tendency to imagine
what it would be like to be at the show when I am listening to a live recording.
I get charged up with songs like The Lion From The North and then it's a
different kind of energy as you listen to the crowd chanting along in the slower
tracks, like The Price Of A Mile. I could picture myself chanting along and
having a good time doing it. It is this way for a little too long, though, in my
opinion.
One point I must address, which adds a little to my reservations about the way
the album flows, is the theme of the chosen selection of songs. It is a bit
difficult to get in to it unless you're passionate about such themes, which I am
not, and in that regard the flow of the album is in question again. Even though
it is live it feels almost like a concept album. Kinda like Maiden have done
before. It might be easy to criticise a band that, lyrically, are very well
known for their tendency to focus on war themes drawn from specific battles and
real life historic events. That's why
I was quite relieved when the pace changed. I mean, if you're singing about very
similar themes throughout, and you're going from song to song in a
sprint/walk/sprint/walk manner (but not enough "CHARGE!"), there isn't really
anything new. This is the pattern from the start, but refreshingly once we get
to Midway (a song the crowd chose) the stop/start progression of the set list
comes to an end and it's not a moment too soon. From that point on we do get the
aforementioned charge I think many people listening to this might be waiting
for. I think the DVD/Blu-Ray has to make up for this and probably
will, coming from a person who has only listened and not seen.
Overall - sound balance issues aside - it sounds fairly average, and bear in
the DVD/Blu-Ray release is not just of
this Woodstock (Poland) gig, which over half a million people attended - they
also have extra performances from this tour in 3 other cities which I am looking
forward to seeing. If this was a compilation album rather than a live recording
I would be giving it a fairly average 60/100 for the reasons mentioned. But,
the live factor does generate enough intrigue to compel me
to watch the DVD/Blu-Ray which I think will be a similar case for fans of Sabaton and the Power Metal genre. They could have made a bit more effort with
the artwork, too. Fairly bland, my rating of that reflects the fact that it's
left me ambivalent. I don't like or dislike it.